Guide · Soda
Is there such a thing as a healthy soda?
Short answer
The healthiest soda is plain soda water: no sugar, no calories. After that, the less sugar the better. A regular 330 mL cola has about 35 g of sugar, more than the 25 g a day WHO suggests as the ideal limit. Diet and zero sodas cut the sugar but swap in sweeteners; prebiotic sodas add a few grams of fibre. Read the sugar per 100 mL first.
Soda types compared: sugar, calories and what replaces the sugar
| Type | Sugar | Calories | What else to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Regular cola or lemon-lime soda | About 35 g (8–9 tsp) | About 140 | Colas add phosphoric acid (INS 338) and caffeine |
| Diet / zero-sugar soda | 0 g | 0–5 | Sweetened with aspartame, acesulfame K, sucralose or stevia |
| Soda water / sparkling water | 0 g | 0 | Some add a little sodium bicarbonate or salt |
| Tonic water (regular) | About 25–30 g | About 100–120 | Quinine gives the bitterness; it isn't sugar-free unless it says so |
| Nimbu soda / masala soda (made fresh) | Whatever's added | 0–150 | Ask for it without sugar, or with half |
| Prebiotic soda | Usually 2–5 g | 20–50 | 2–9 g of fibre, often chicory inulin; sweetened with stevia or fruit juice |
| Fruit "drink" (not juice) | Often 30–45 g | 120–180 | "Drink" or "nectar" means added water and sugar |
WHO's guideline is to keep free sugars under 10% of daily energy, and ideally under 5%: about 25 g a day for an adult (WHO, 2015). One regular cola is already past that.
Why the sugar in soda matters more than the sugar in food
Liquid sugar doesn't fill you up the way food does, so its calories mostly add to what you eat rather than replace it. A meta-analysis of cohort studies found that people drinking one to two sugary drinks a day had about a 26% higher risk of type 2 diabetes than people who rarely drank them (Malik et al., 2010). That's an association, not proof, but it's a consistent one.
- sugar in a regular 330 mL cola
- ~35 g
- WHO's ideal daily limit for free sugars
- 25 g
- calories a month saved by swapping one can a day for water
- ~4,000
Is diet or zero-sugar soda healthy?
It's better than sugary soda for your teeth and your calorie count, and in randomised trials swapping sugar for low-calorie sweeteners led to slightly more weight loss, about 0.8 kg on average (Miller and Perez, 2014). But WHO advised in 2023 against relying on non-sugar sweeteners for weight control, because long-term studies don't show lasting benefit (WHO, 2023).
On aspartame specifically: in 2023 IARC classed it as "possibly carcinogenic" (its weakest category, based on limited evidence), while WHO's food additive committee kept the acceptable daily intake at 40 mg per kg of body weight. WHO's own example: a 70 kg adult would need more than 9 to 14 cans of diet soda a day to exceed it (WHO, 2023).
How to pick a healthier soda in India: a 6-point label check
- Total sugars per 100 mL. Indian labels must show it. Under 2.5 g is light; over 8 g is a full-sugar soft drink. Multiply by 3.3 for a 330 mL can.
- Added sugars. Also on the label since the 2020 rules. Natural fruit sugar and added sugar count the same to your body, but the added figure tells you what the brand chose.
- The sweetener, by INS number. 950 is acesulfame K, 951 aspartame, 954 saccharin, 955 sucralose, 960 steviol glycosides (stevia).
- Caffeine. Colas and "energy" sodas carry it; the label has to say so. Skip it in the evening and for children.
- Fibre, if it claims gut health. Grams per can. Most trials of prebiotic fibre used 5 g or more a day; see prebiotic soda.
- Proof of what's inside. The FSSAI licence number on the pack, and ideally a batch lab report. How to read one.
More on every line of the label, from the ingredient order to "no added sugar", in how to read a drink label.
Healthy alternatives to Coke and other colas
- Soda water with lime and a pinch of salt. The classic nimbu soda, minus the sugar. Soda water's benefits and side effects.
- Zero-sugar cola, if it's the taste you want. Count it as a treat, not a water.
- Unsweetened iced tea or cold coffee, for the caffeine without the sugar.
- Chaas (buttermilk) or plain coconut water in the heat. Coconut water has natural sugar, about 3–6 g per 100 mL, so it isn't zero.
- Plain or functional water, if you want something with a job: see functional water.
Is Get Waisted making a soda?
We're considering it. Get Waisted makes two still waters today, HMPA Water and L-Carnitine Water, and we're weighing a sparkling version. Nothing is decided and nothing is on sale.
Questions people ask
What is the healthiest soda?
Plain soda water or sparkling water: no sugar and no calories. After that, choose the soda with the least sugar per 100 mL, and decide whether you're comfortable with the sweetener that replaced it.
Which soft drink is healthy in India?
None of the full-sugar ones: a regular 330 mL cola has about 35 g of sugar, more than WHO's ideal daily limit of about 25 g. Soda water, zero-sugar sodas and low-sugar prebiotic sodas are the lighter options; check the total sugars per 100 mL on the label.
Is diet soda healthy?
It's better than sugary soda for calories and teeth, and swapping one for the other led to slightly more weight loss in trials. WHO advised in 2023 against relying on non-sugar sweeteners for long-term weight control, so treat diet soda as a step down from sugar, not as water.
Is zero sugar soda bad for you?
Not in normal amounts. The sweeteners used in India are approved by FSSAI within limits, and WHO's example is that a 70 kg adult would need more than 9 to 14 cans a day to exceed aspartame's acceptable intake. It still isn't a substitute for water.
What is a healthy alternative to Coke?
Soda water with lime, a zero-sugar cola if it's the taste you miss, unsweetened iced tea, or chaas. The biggest win is replacing the 35 g of sugar in a regular can.
Are prebiotic sodas healthy?
They're usually lower in sugar than regular soda, which is the main benefit. Most carry 2 to 9 g of fibre per can, and most trials of prebiotic fibre used 5 g or more a day, so a single low-fibre can does little for your gut on its own.
Is Get Waisted making a soda?
We're considering a sparkling version of our waters. Nothing is decided and nothing is on sale. If we make one, it will show its sugar and every ingredient amount, and come with a lab report for every batch, like our still waters.
Sources
- 01World Health Organization (2015). Guideline: Sugars intake for adults and children.WHO guideline
- 02Malik V.S. et al. (2010). Sugar-sweetened beverages and risk of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes: a meta-analysis. Diabetes Care 33(11):2477–2483.Peer-reviewed · meta-analysis
- 03Miller P.E., Perez V. (2014). Low-calorie sweeteners and body weight and composition: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 100(3):765–777.Peer-reviewed · meta-analysis
- 04World Health Organization (2023). Use of non-sugar sweeteners: WHO guideline.WHO guideline
- 05WHO, IARC and JECFA (14 July 2023): Aspartame hazard and risk assessment results released.WHO
- 06FSSAI: Frequently asked questions on the Food Safety and Standards (Labelling and Display) Regulations, 2020.Regulator (India)
Keep reading
- Guide · Soda waterIs soda water good for you?Is soda water good for health? Real benefits (digestion, fullness), side effects (teeth, bloating, reflux), weight loss, and soda vs sparkling vs tonic water.→
- Guide · Functional sodaWhat is prebiotic soda, and does it work?Prebiotic soda explained: how much fibre helps your gut, side effects, India's new prebiotic sodas, and Japan's fat-burning Coke (Coca-Cola Plus).→
- Guide · TransparencyHow to read a drink label in IndiaRead any drink label in India: sugar per 100 mL, added sugar, INS numbers, sugar free vs no added sugar, caffeine and the FSSAI licence number.→
Sparkling · being considered
Report first. Can second.
We're deciding whether our waters go sparkling. Leave an email and you'll hear first, with the lab report, if we make one. Free, no payment.