Guide · Water

Canned water vs plastic bottles: is a can better?

Short answer

A can keeps out light and air, so water tastes the same months later, and it avoids the plastic particles that studies keep finding in bottled water: one 2024 study counted about 240,000 per litre, mostly nanoplastics. Cans are lined with a thin coating, so ask what it is. Aluminium can be recycled again and again; most plastic bottles get one more life at best.

Updated By Get Waisted editorial4 sources · 3 min

How much plastic is in bottled water?

More than anyone counted until recently. A 2018 study of 259 bottles from 11 brands across 9 countries, India included, found synthetic polymer particles in 93% of them (Mason et al., 2018). In 2024, a new imaging method found about 240,000 plastic particles per litre in bottled water, around 90% of them nanoplastics too small for earlier methods to see (Qian et al., 2024).

What these particles do in the body is still being studied, and no safe or unsafe level has been set. What's known is where many come from: the bottle and its cap, worn by heat, squeezing and time.

Can vs plastic bottle vs glass

Three ways to package water
Aluminium canPlastic (PET) bottleGlass bottle
Light and airBlocks both completelyLets some through over timeBlocks air; clear glass lets in light
Plastic contactA thin inner liningThe whole bottle and capUsually only the cap liner
ResealableNo (most cans)YesYes
Weight to shipLightLightestHeavy
RecyclingCan be recycled repeatedly without losing qualityUsually downcycled into fibre or other productsRecyclable; heavy to collect
ChillsFastSlowerSlow

Are aluminium cans safe? The lining question

Every drinks can has a thin coating inside so the drink never touches bare metal. Older linings used epoxy resins made with BPA; many can makers have moved to BPA-free ("BPA-NI") coatings. The lining is tiny compared with a whole plastic bottle, but it's still a material in contact with your drink, so it's a fair question to ask any brand that sells water in a can. We'll publish what ours is lined with before we launch.

What Indian rules cover for packaged water

Plain packaged drinking water and natural mineral water sold in India need the BIS ISI mark: IS 14543 and IS 13428 respectively (BIS). Water with added ingredients, such as functional water, falls under FSSAI's food rules instead. Either way, the maker has to test, but nothing requires the report to be shown to you: see what lab-tested means.

Why Get Waisted uses a can

Both our waters, HMPA Water and L-Carnitine Water, come in a 330 mL aluminium can: it keeps the ingredient away from light and air, it chills fast, and the can is where the QR code that opens each batch's lab report lives. If we make the sparkling version we're considering, a can holds the fizz better than plastic too.

Questions people ask

Is canned water better than bottled water?

A can blocks light and air and avoids the plastic bottle that studies link to microplastics and nanoplastics in water. It isn't resealable, and it has a thin inner lining, so ask what that lining is made of.

How many microplastics are in bottled water?

A 2024 study using a new imaging method found about 240,000 plastic particles per litre of bottled water, around 90% of them nanoplastics. A 2018 study found synthetic particles in 93% of 259 bottles from 9 countries, India included.

Are aluminium cans safe for water?

Cans are lined so water doesn't touch the metal. Older linings used BPA-based epoxy; many makers now use BPA-free coatings. Ask the brand which lining its cans use.

Is bottled water safe in India?

Packaged drinking water needs the BIS ISI mark (IS 14543), and mineral water IS 13428, which set limits on contaminants. Microplastics aren't covered by those limits yet. Keep bottles out of the sun and heat.

Does canned water taste different?

It shouldn't. Because the can blocks light and air, canned water usually tastes the same months later. Any metallic taste suggests a damaged lining.

Is there canned water in India?

A few brands sell it. Get Waisted's two functional waters, HMPA Water and L-Carnitine Water, will come in 330 mL aluminium cans, each with a QR code that opens its batch lab report. Neither is on sale yet.

Sources

  1. 01Mason S.A. et al. (2018). Synthetic polymer contamination in bottled water. Frontiers in Chemistry 6:407.Peer-reviewed · 259 bottles, 9 countries
  2. 02Qian N. et al. (2024). Rapid single-particle chemical imaging of nanoplastics by SRS microscopy. PNAS 121(3):e2300582121.Peer-reviewed · bottled water
  3. 03Bureau of Indian Standards: products under compulsory certification (packaged drinking water IS 14543, natural mineral water IS 13428).Regulator (India)
  4. 04FSS (Licensing and Registration of Food Businesses) Regulations, 2011, Annexure 3, Conditions of Licence, no. 12: testing "through own or NABL accredited / FSSA notified labs at least once in six months".Regulation (India)

Both waters · in a can

Report first. Can second.

HMPA Water and L-Carnitine Water, 330 mL aluminium, a lab report for every batch. Reserve a pack free.

Free. No payment. One email per batch.